Murdoku case 36
A Messy Situation — Solution, Hints & Walkthrough
- Hard
- 9 × 9 grid
- 8 suspects
Clue cards
- AAbigail
She was alone.
- BBen
He was southeast of Abigail and northwest of Hawa
- CCarl
He was on a mud puddle.
- DDavid
He was alone with Carl.
- EEdgar
He was beside a tree.
- FFrance
She was on a mud puddle.
- GGrace
She was sitting in a chair. She was exactly one row north of France.
- HHawa
She was not beside a table.
- VValentinoVictim
The Victim. He was alone with the murderer.
Crime scene
Map objects
Tree
Table
Chair
Opening hint A place to start
Use the occupancy rule to separate the two pairs from the people who have to be alone.
Show walkthrough Includes placements
- Nine people fill seven occupied areas. C and D share one area, and V shares another with the murderer. The other five people must be alone.
- G is one row north of F. If G were in the Restroom in row 3, F would use the Kitchen's last row. G must sit in the Living Room while F uses the Porch mud. Cross out R6C1, R7C3, and R8C6.
- C needs mud and company from D. The Restroom would block the Kitchen, and G needs the Living Room to herself. Place C at R1C4 and D at R2C7 in the Back Yard. E goes at R9C9.
- The Kitchen and Restroom use rows 3 and 4. A is northwest of B and B is northwest of H. This puts A at R3C2 in the Kitchen and B at R4C6 in the Restroom.
- H takes R6C8 in the Bedroom, so G goes at R7C1 and F at R8C3. V takes R5C5 in the Living Room.
Reveal the answer Murderer and final grid
Murderer Grace (G) R7C1
Valentino is at R5C5 and shares Living Room with only Grace.
| ID | Person | Square |
|---|---|---|
| A | Abigail | R3C2 |
| B | Ben | R4C6 |
| C | Carl | R1C4 |
| D | David | R2C7 |
| E | Edgar | R9C9 |
| F | France | R8C3 |
| G | Grace | R7C1 |
| H | Hawa | R6C8 |
| V | Valentino | R5C5 |